Our place in the ‘new politics’….

Matthew Engel has an interesting article in today’s Financial Times saying, quite rightly, that talk of a new politics is a horrid cliche which gets trotted by every leader who feels that conveniently they represent this new divine paradigm. However, looking at the Norwich North result Engel feels we are effectively in an ‘Eight party system’.  While this has an aspect of truth to it one big factor that mitigates against this new kind of politics taking hold is the electoral system which simply doesn’t allow the space for such a system to exist in terms of Westminster representation.

Try and try UKIP and the Green’s will but the likelihood of them gaining a single MP is still slim and the odds are stacked heavily against them. Were the system to be changed even to AV+ however this would change and Engel’s eight-party system might finally manifest at Westminster. As I have said before this new reality needs us as a party to come to terms with some uncomfortable home truths; we are no longer a protest party and will likely see our protest vote slip-slide away gradually. So, our campaigning has to change to recognise that there are not going to be anymore shock by-election victories and it actually has to reflect a serious desire to build the party into one that one day will challenge for government.

Policy-wise we have to however maintain our distinctiveness of value driven commitmentsand priorities. Nick Clegg wants to solve the policy dilemma negatively and move our party to his own brand of ‘realpolitik’ or else in the instance of Afghanistan commit us to policies which reflect the wrong values and priorities and ironically are not very realistic when it comes to an on-the-ground assessment. Every year our conferenceends with an upbeat ‘Go back to your constituencies and prepare for government’ kind of rousing speech which in the actual situation is pretty meaningless because we are nowhere near the leavers of power; it is more said for psychological reinforcement.

However, while in the ‘new politics’ we are going to lose our place as a protest party it does also present us with an opportunity to redefine ourselves in that direction; whether it will be taken or not remains to be seen.


Tags: , ,

About darrellgoodliffe


4 responses to “Our place in the ‘new politics’….”

  1. James Graham says :

    “Were the system to be changed even to AV+ however this would change and Engel’s eight-party system might finally manifest at Westminster.”

    No it wouldn’t – not under AV+. Maybe the Greens and UKIP would pick up 1 or 2 seats that way but it is nothing like proportional enough to give them proper representation.


  2. Costigan Quist says :

    If you look at the party’s actual campaigning, both in the air war and elections, it’s clear that the people who decide these things realised a while back that we could no longer go for the protest vote.

    It’s one of the reasons that the positioning of the party as pro-liberty is so important.

    Exactly how we would campaign in a real PR system is a tough one – I’ve argued in the past that PR for Westminster wouldn’t be the ticket to loads of seats but would present the party with some very tough challenges indeed.


  3. wit and wisdom says :

    I’d say we have moved a log way from being the party of protest to being a party people at least listen to seriously. The key issue in that regard is persuading people to cross that credibility gap from quite liking what we say to actually supporting us.

    As Costigan points out, Nickers has done much good work to re-position us, often to the annoyance of many party members but I agree with your fundamental thesis – and I’ve been banging on in a similar vein for some time – that we need to have a good hard think about exactly what we are out to achieve. I hope its power, because if it isn’t we might as well all just go home.


  4. darrellgoodliffe says :


    True but then again you know my views on this debate. It would certainly give both UKIP and the Greens a foothold though.


    To be fair that is not immediatly obvious to me and this repositioning doesnt seem to have had an actual effect. Agreed that PR would present different challenges though and that it would not be a given that we would benefit.


    Depends what you mean on some policy issues where I dont agree with Clegg as is known. However, dont you feel that he often tries to the protest party angle saying we are the real opposition to an incoming Conservative government etc?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: