Nobodies sums add-up….surely that is the point?

If the election campaign is going to be one giant Dutch-auction of claim/counterclaim regarding public spending then it could be a less exciting spectacle than people think it will be. Alistair Darling led the way today by claiming that there is a £34 billion gap in the Conservatives spending proposals.

David Cameron joined in by rebutting the claims and at the same time launching a poster-campaign in which he claimed that he would ‘cut the deficit, not the NHS’. If he really wants to convince people of his honourable intent when it comes to the NHS then he really should choose his friends more wisely.

 Vince Cable agrees with Alistair Darling;

“The Tory sums simply do not stack up. It is irresponsible and highly misleading for George Osborne to continue to pretend that they do.

You might think Vince would be on safe-ground here but there are elements to the less-is-more ‘Mansion Tax sop to the Shires’ that don’t make for convincing mathematics either.

The wider point is that nobodies sums will add-up entirely. Why? Well for the opposition they are often going on officially produced figures which will be wide-of-the-mark while the governments figures and commitments will be predicated on predicting the future (ie, economic growth and projected tax revenues etc). So, this debate takes place within the backdrop of a certain amount of theoretical abstraction. It is thus theoretically possible for two seemingly contradictory statements to be true; with the ultimately true one only being determined in the concrete future. 

Also, you have to deal with a certain amount of political ‘slight-of-hand’ when things are ‘re-catergorised’ to give the impression of a continuation of investment while cuts are made behind the scenes elsewhere. This debate is all about what is happening between-the-lines; the language of political priorities that each party speaks.

Labour should be insisting that its priority is a return on the investment this nation made in saving capitalism; that it pays dividends in terms of the market being made truly the servant of the people. Some tax cuts for those lower down the scale might even be nice as might some investment in ‘green industary’. The Conservatives priority is to shrink the state driven as they are by the increasingly moth-eared neo-liberal orthodoxy that the same thing that had to be saved by the state should replace it.  Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrats will sit somewhere between the two as they contemplate the peculiar contradictions that bedevils their discourse.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

About darrellgoodliffe


4 responses to “Nobodies sums add-up….surely that is the point?”

  1. DerekGoodliffe says :

    Are you saying that the Lib-dems will be sitting on the fence,Again?. I feel that all the top three,bye the way,who are the top three these days? All the partys need to stop the bullshit, and start to come out with their nailed on does and dont,s,coz the general public are wanting to know where there are gonna be after the election. If it goes the way of the Tory,s , then we are gonna be in for a rough ride, they have not changed,and wont, they look after the well to do,and sod the rest, Labour needs to get back to some good old Socialist ways, as for the Lib-Dems, they need to find their way,or they will suffer the worst I feel.


  2. darrellgoodliffe says :

    We never sit on the fence *cough*…agreed that the Conservatives will be bad about Labour and the Lib Dems….


  3. Trampoline Pads Man says :

    Forget talking about cuts and tax rises, they will never get the deficit cut that way. The only real debate should be about growth. Grow our economy and keep spending under control and we can get back in equilibrium.
    Who has the best plan for growth?


  4. darrellgoodliffe says :


    Agreed. I am not sure to be honest, both Labour and the Lib Dems mutter about investment but certainly in the latters case it has slipped down the agenda.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: