Crossing the threshold….

5 days to go and currently only 3 candidates have been nominated by enough MP’s to appear on the ballot paper with an entry of a fourth in Andy Burnham looking possible and the exclusion of both the left’s candidates; Diane Abbott and John McDonnell looking likely. Although there are 5 days have passed I would be surprised if either now gets on the ballot paper; one may have had a chance (assuming things would have panned out evenly, a left candidate would now be over half way to 33 on 17). What will ultimately deprive the left of a clear candidate is the split and no matter what grievances there are against the rules I feel the maths will ultimately support me on this.

So, what about those rules? Diane Abbott clearly doesn’t like them and feels they were put in place to obstruct the left; however, I am not as completely convinced as her that it is right to just blame them. As I have outlined above there are compelling reasons to feel disunity is possibly what will cost the left its candidate which is one good reason to not totally subscribe to the Abbott narrative. I am also not really convinced that 33 as a number has magical properties in and of itself that wards off leftism and I accept the point that the leader has to command sufficient support within the PLP to actually lead.

Where I am happy to concede ground to the Abbott argument is that it is wrong to nominate solely on the basis of the judgment of 33 (or more) members of the PLP. Our Party in its entirety should be involved at a much earlier stage and nomination should count for something (which may ensure the Party at least gets a balanced contest). Currently, the system makes nomination of candidates the sole prerogative of the PLP and this in my eyes is wrong. Our Party is a coalition but a composite of different parts from its Parliamentary to its trade union components and it is wrong for the PLP to have quite the suzerainty it does (MP’s votes should not be weighted) because the leader of the Labour Party leads more than the PLP; they lead a composite movement in many ways; the labour movement and they should have to win the confidence of sufficient numbers of all those parts.

If all the brave talk of transforming this Party is to mean anything then the PLP will have to surrender some of its power; Diane Abbott’s remarks are misdirected; the issue that needs addressing is a more fundamental one and it cannot be solved by merely lowering the bar.


Tags: , , , , ,

About darrellgoodliffe


2 responses to “Crossing the threshold….”

  1. Daniel says :

    I think you largely miss the point about the 33. 33 isn’t a magic number – it’s simply one eighth (rounded up) of the PLP which is what is required to be nominated. And honestly, if someone cannot convince 1/8 of the PLP to nominate them, should they really be on the ballot anyway?

    It is too simplistic to divide the Labour Party into left/right just as it was to divide it into Blair/Brown. Look at the candidates – Abbott and McDonnell don’t have any more in common than Balls and Milliband (D).

    I suspect we will see at least two of the remaining candidates nominated before the nominations close later this week. I genuinely hope that all 6 make it on to the ballot, not least so there can be no bleating from those that claim they never got the choice.


  2. darrellgoodliffe says :


    Thanks for your comment. I quite agree to be honest, I don’t support Abbott in that regard.

    Yes that is simplistic I agree but this is always the case in politics; these lables exist to help explain complicated sets of views.

    I rather hope that one of McDonnell or Abbott (preferably the former in my mind) sees the light and ensures a good contest.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: