Why the GMB were right to endorse Ed….

I am a member of the GMB so was delighted to see their endorsement of Ed Miliband for the Labour Leadership. I  believe the union has made the right decision for its members and for the broader Party. Being endorsed by a union does not mean ‘being captive’ to them. If it does then it is surely correct to argue that David Miliband is the ‘captive’ of Lord Sainsbury? We should resist right-wing fear mongering and certainly not allow it to cloud judgement.

Briefly, a word has to be said about character although as many have said this is not what this election should be about it is part of picking a leader . I think Ed has the right character to unite the party; there is no sense of presumption that leadership and power is expected but more a recognition it must be earned. My personal experience leads me to believe that his elder brother is a much better person than his sometimes ill-judged and badly framed remarks would lead us to believe. Like Tony Blair, I think David Miliband sincerely believes in himself and the ethics he espouses. I think he genuinely feels he himself has the best interests of those he aspires to represent at heart.

However, much like Tony Blair, it is this messianic conviction that ultimately is his undoing. It is also worth noting that it is this that led Blair into the fatally flawed and just plain wrong invasion of Iraq. I find myself unconvinced that the elder Miliband would not be led astray in a similar way because ultimately what he says may be the sign of a heart in the right place but it’s not grounded enough to keep the head travelling in the same direction. This is something that is worryingly confirmed by the latest revelations about the last governments complicity in torture. Means do not necessarily justify the end Mr Miliband; they also have a crucial bearing on the entire destination.

Looking at the stated policy platform, the younger Miliband has much more on offer and his social democracy is much more practical in nature. His ‘Living Wage’ campaign strikes at the root cause of the inequality that the elder so eloquently states he wishes to fight against; incomes and their disparity. This should, in Ed’s case, lead to a wider examination of the role and the trade unions and seeing them as our friends and natural allies in the struggle to fight inequality. Strong unions will be a strong counterweight to the income inequality which in no small measure has led to the current financial mess. A Mansion Tax sounds good but it serves no other function than to punish excess; it does nothing on its own to redress the balance. Similarly, it should be a no-brainer when asking yourself to choose between the charitable status of private schools and free school meals for the disadvantaged.

Trade unionists should consider Ed Miliband their natural ally and candidate they should prefer and Labour Party members should as well; Ed is the right person in the here and now to lead this Party forward and restore alot of its lost core values.


Tags: , , ,

About darrellgoodliffe


2 responses to “Why the GMB were right to endorse Ed….”

  1. Bob Dyson says :

    Whilst I think the weight of your argument is justified and I will probably vote the same way myself, I would have liked the opportunity to put in my own four penny worth. As far as I know the GMB has not had a hustings in the the north let alone in Leeds, my home city. The place of the largest and longest and strongest “winning” strike action in recent history, how quickly we forget?

    We have had to make do with sneaking in the back door of the Unite show at the Queens Hotel! and the Labour Party q & a’s at the Leeds Met & the Playhouse, (by the way I did not see many front line GMB people there either).

    Modern day Trade Unionism is all about consultation and to date there has not been any, no one wants to know my opinion, no one has asked me what I think as one of the few GMB people I saw at any of these events bar one, Mark Crampton. London (GMB HQ) is all to often, happy to dictate/suggest? to the rank and file what we should be doing at any one particular moment in our lives, I think I’ll make my own mind up on the balance of what I learnt at the events I attended, shame the GMB could not have sponsored some events “up north”, it was an ideal recruiting opportunity missed.

    Bob Dyson
    City wide Convenor
    Leeds City Council


  2. darrellgoodliffe says :


    Certainly agree that there should have been an opportunity for GMB members to have their say. I am not aware of one happening either.

    I cant say much else other than totally agree with all your points.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: